The UK government’s plan to grant “single malt” status to English whisky has ignited controversy between English and Scottish whisky producers. The English Whisky Guild (EWG) has applied for geographical indication (GI) status, aiming to legally define “English whisky.” The Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) opposes the move, arguing that it could devalue the “single malt” designation and threaten Scotland’s whisky industry.
Get your weekly whisky roundup featuring current events and industry insights—sign up for our free whisky newsletter.
Key Takeaways
The English Whisky Guild seeks GI status for “English whisky” and “English whiskey.”
The SWA opposes the proposal, arguing it undermines Scotch single malt’s prestige.
Scottish politicians warn the move could harm Scotland’s £5.4 billion whisky industry.
Defra’s public consultation on the issue closes on May 19, 2025.
The final decision could significantly impact whisky production and exports in the UK.
Defining English Whisky: The EWG’s Proposal
The EWG has submitted an application for GI status, seeking to formally establish “English whisky” and “English whiskey” as distinct categories. The proposed criteria mandate that English whisky must be distilled and matured in England using UK-sourced grains and water. However, unlike Scotch whisky regulations, the definition allows for mashing and fermentation to take place off-site, provided that distillation occurs at a single English distillery.
Supporters argue that this definition aligns with international standards and allows English distilleries to collaborate with breweries, leveraging their brewing expertise to create unique whisky expressions. The EWG also points to similar practices permitted in Wales and the United States as justification for the proposal.
Scotch Whisky Industry Pushes Back
The SWA has voiced strong opposition to the proposal, emphasizing that Scotch single malt whisky requires mashing, fermentation, and distillation to take place at the same site. This ensures an “integral connection to place,” which they argue is fundamental to single malt production. The SWA contends that allowing off-site mashing and fermentation could dilute the prestige of the “single malt” designation, potentially harming Scotch whisky’s global reputation.
Scottish politicians have echoed these concerns. First Minister John Swinney pledged that the Scottish government would make “all necessary representations” to protect Scotch whisky’s identity. Meanwhile, SNP MP Graham Leadbitter called the proposal an “act of sabotage,” warning that it could undermine Scotland’s £5.4 billion whisky sector.
Government Consultation and Industry Impact
The UK’s Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) has launched a three-month public consultation on the GI application, running until May 19, 2025. Stakeholders, including whisky producers, industry groups, and consumers, are encouraged to submit feedback. No final decision has been made on whether English whisky will receive GI recognition.
The debate comes at a turbulent time for Scotch whisky producers, who are grappling with rising production costs and shifting consumer preferences. In 2024, Scotch whisky exports declined by 3.7% to £5.4 billion, with single malt exports dropping 17% to £1.7 billion. Industry leaders fear that recognizing English whisky as a GI could further impact exports and employment in Scotland’s whisky sector.
What’s Next for English Whisky?
As the consultation progresses, tensions between English and Scottish whisky producers remain high. The outcome of this proposal could reshape the whisky industry in the UK, influencing market perceptions, production methods, and international trade agreements. With stakeholders on both sides making strong arguments, the final decision will have lasting implications for the future of whisky in Britain.
To receive your weekly whisky industry news roundup, sign up for our free whisky newsletter.
Share on social media:
